People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Sister ordered J&Js for dinner and wasn't disappointed. The delivery driver guy was nice. We had stuffed pizza with sausage,mushrooms, green peppers & peperoni. It's not bad for a stuffed pizza . We also had an Italian beef with mozzarella cheese and pepperoncinis. The sandwich was hot and delicious. I definitely recommend this place for something different to eat.. ”
“ delicious!! wish we lived closer but my boyfriend and I traveled from Ohio for a concert and wanted pizza while we were in town. top 5 pizza place ever for sure. we had a deep dish supreme. came with a free 2 liter by surprise! love. workers were also very friendly. thank you:) ”
“ This place was everything I was hoping for out of a community minded eatery. I was here for about an hour. The entire time I watched they were busy. The people around here LOVED the food. Folks were coming in non stop to pick up orders, calling continuously to place orders. I noticed a strange phenomenon in which as people were carrying food out others were jumping at the chance to hold the door for them. Until my own food arrived I didn't realize why. J&Js stacks topping on their pizza until they are heavy. The customer culture here just knows that a person carrying a pizza from this place needs a hand with the door. I started this review with that thought because if you are looking for dining ambiance this ain't the place. They have a lot of pinball machines and that's cool but I can tell the owners put priority on food which once you try it you will understand. If you are looking for good pizza try this place, just don't be upset about the wait. The wait is because they are busy. They are busy because they are good. Well worth the wait. ”
“ Haven’t had my JJ’s deep dish kitchen sink pizza fix in years. Finally got one today. Absolute heaven! Just as amazing as I remembered! Sooooo good. You guys are the bomb!! Thank you ”
“ Their stuffed crust kitchen sink is my ALL time favorite pizza! I live about 2 hours away so every time I get up that way I gotta grab a pizza. ”
“ When you are feeling hungry and don't feel like leaving the house J&J's Pizza Shack is the way to go. We have ordered from them for years now and it's Always a good experience! They offer delivery and there drivers are very punctual, showing up before the quoted time of delivery many times. We get the Stuffed Crust Pizza with Peperoni and Chunk Italian Sausage and it is Always Delicious, Hot and Fresh! The Garlic Bread with Cheese is Amazing too! We are Repeat and Happy customers! Thank you ”
“ JJs is fantastic pizza! Never fails. Always consistent, love both the think crust and deep dish! Keep up the great work! ”
“ I miss this pizza. I haven't found pizza better than jjs. I live in Ohio now. I visit just to get this pizza. So that's saying something Bathroom always clean They have some games here Stuffed crust is the best one!! ”
Menu
Jalapeno Poppers
Taco Pizza
Chicken Dinner
Wing Dinner
Bucket Of Wings (48)
About
J&J's Pizza Shack
Welcome to the delicious world of J&J's Pizza Shack, a local gem nestled in the heart of Valparaiso, IN. Located at 1454 Lincolnway, this pizza paradise has become a beloved community spot where hearty flavors and friendly service intertwine.
As a food reviewer for Foodjoyy, I’m excited to dive into what makes J&J's Pizza Shack a standout destination for pizza lovers and sandwich enthusiasts alike. The establishment isn't just about satisfying hunger; it’s about creating an experience that keeps customers returning for more.
- Specialty Pizzas: The menu boasts an impressive array of specialty pizzas, including the indulgent Kitchen Sink pizza, loaded with ground sausage, pepperoni, and a delightful medley of toppings. For those yearning for comfort in a crust, the deep dish Supreme and Meat Pie provide a hearty satisfaction that leaves patrons craving another slice.
- Sandwiches: Pair your pizza with one of their classic sandwiches like the Italian Beef smothered in mozzarella, or the Grilled Chicken Sandwich, featuring crisp lettuce and juicy tomato. These selections prove that J&J's is not a one-trick pony when it comes to satisfying your cravings.
- Desserts: Don’t forget to leave room for dessert! Their Eli's Cheesecake and Lemon Cake Roll promise a sweet ending to your meal.
The atmosphere at J&J's Pizza Shack is unique and relaxed, with an undeniable community spirit. Customers like Rich rave about the lively environment, highlighting the camaraderie among patrons eager to help each other out. The bustling vibe, complemented by pinball machines, creates a casual backdrop for enjoying a meal that's clearly made with love.
Reviews reflect the quality and care poured into each dish; Nadia Ray even hails it as one of the top five pizza places ever after traveling from Ohio, a testament to the Shack’s broad acclaim. And if you're wondering about wait times—Rich aptly notes the wait reflects the love local customers have for the food. After sampling dishes, it’s easy to see why folks are more than willing to wait; the results are worth every minute.
For those looking for a mouthwatering meal that blends community spirit with incredible flavors, J&J's Pizza Shack should be at the top of your list. Whether you're a local seeking comfort food or a traveler on the hunt for hidden culinary treasures, J&J's is ready to welcome you with open arms and a slice of their delicious pizza. Don’t miss out on this culinary experience—your taste buds will thank you!
You can reach them by phone at +1 219-476-1616 for takeout or to place an order. Trust me; once you try the food at J&J's, you're bound to be hooked!
Book a table